ProcessModel 7 Self Teach GuideChapter 9

Chapter 9. Make Each Repair Wait for Its Part

By the end of this chapter you can

Make a step wait for parts from a shelf that reorders itself.

Watch the video (4 minutes), then work through the lesson below it in ProcessModel, step by step.

Title card: Self Teach Guide, Chapter 9. Make each repair wait for its part.

Chapter 9 watched

Now work through the lesson

The video could not be played here.

Watch on YouTube
Length 4 minutes 26 seconds

Before you start

Until now, a repair could start the moment a Technician was free. A real repair also needs a part: a screen, a battery, a connector. Parts run out, a new box takes time to arrive, and while the shelf is empty, nothing gets repaired, however many Technicians are standing by.

This chapter teaches how to model stock that is used up and reordered:

  • An Inventory is a stock location: a shelf of named items. It sits beside the flow; no route goes in or out of it. Logic reaches it by name.
  • A reorder rule keeps it stocked: when the stock falls to the Reorder Level, it orders the Reorder Qty, which arrives after the Lead Time.
  • REQUEST is the logic that takes stock. If the part is not there, the customer waits until it is.

Here is what changes in the shop:

PartChapter 8Chapter 9
Parts ShelfNoneA shelf holding one item, Part. It starts empty; a box of ten is ordered when three are left, and takes two hours to arrive
Repair QueueA place to wait for a TechnicianEach customer also takes one part here before Repair, and waits without one
Everything elseAs Chapter 8 left itUnchanged

You need your Phone Repair Shop from Chapter 8 (or the practice model below) and about thirty minutes.

Step 1. Open your shop

  1. On the Welcome screen, under Recent Models, click Phone Repair Shop.

Step 2. Add the Parts Shelf

  1. Rest the pointer on More, the double chevron in the palette. A list of advanced shapes opens.
The palette with its More list open, headed Advanced Nodes: Batch, Unbatch, Gate, Inventory, Signal, Transition and Process Group.
Figure 1. The advanced shapes, under More in the palette.
  1. Drag an Inventory onto the canvas and drop it under the Repair Queue, clear of every line.
  2. Name it Parts Shelf.

Step 3. Stock the shelf with a reorder rule

  1. Click the Items tab, then Add Item.
  2. Click Name and type Part. Quantity, the stock on the shelf when the day starts, stays at 0: the first box is ordered at once and lands overnight.
The Parts Shelf's Items tab with Item 1: Name (SKU) Part, Zone None, Quantity 0, then Capacity, Unit Cost, Unit Time and Reorder Level below.
Figure 2. One item, Part, starting at 0.
  1. Scroll down. Set Lead Time Unit to Hr, and type 2 in Lead Time: a box takes two hours to arrive.
  2. In Reorder Qty, type 10: a box holds ten parts.
  3. In Reorder Level, type 3: when three are left, the next box is ordered.
Further down the Parts Shelf's Items tab: Reorder Level 3, Reorder Qty 10, Reorder Policy Fixed Quantity, Max Outstanding Orders 1, Lead Time 2 and Lead Time Unit Hr.
Figure 3. The reorder rule: at 3 left, order 10, which take 2 hours to arrive.

Think about what these three numbers do together. A box is ordered at three left and takes two hours. If the shop uses more than three parts in those two hours, the shelf runs dry before the box lands. That is a stockout, and this run will show you one.

Step 4. Make each repair take a part

Where should a customer take the part? At the Repair Queue, not at Repair, and the reason is worth understanding. Repair’s own logic runs once a Technician has been given to the customer, so a customer waiting there for a part would keep a Technician standing idle, unable to help at Quick Fix. In the Repair Queue the customer waits for the part, and both Technicians stay free.

  1. Click the Repair Queue, open its Logic tab, and click Compose.
  2. Click Add Action, search for REQUEST from, and pick it.
  3. Type Part for the item and Parts Shelf for where it comes from. The names must match the item and the shelf exactly.
The Action Logic Builder for the Repair Queue with one card: REQUEST 1 Part FROM Parts Shelf.
Figure 4. REQUEST 1 Part FROM Parts Shelf.
  1. Click Save Logic.
The Repair Queue's Logic tab showing REQUEST 1 "Part" FROM "Parts Shelf".
Figure 5. The line the card wrote: each customer takes one part before Repair, and waits in the queue without one.

Step 5. Watch the shelf

  1. Click Run Simulation and watch the Parts Shelf. During the run it shows its stock as Qty.

Overnight, the first box lands: the shelf reads 10.

The shop before 7 in the morning. The Parts Shelf reads Qty 10.
Figure 6. The first box has landed overnight: ten parts on the shelf.

From 7, each repair takes one part, and the count goes down. When three are left, an orange low mark shows and a new box is ordered. Then watch what happens when the shelf reaches 0:

  • Customers in the Repair Queue wait for a part.
  • The queue fills, and, just as in Chapter 6, a full queue stops Check In.
  • Repair and Quick Fix stand idle: the Technicians are free, but there is nothing they can repair.
The shop just after noon. The Parts Shelf reads Qty 0. The Repair Queue is full, Check In is busy and red, and the cards read Throughput 27.5 per day, Avg Throughput Time 25 min, WIP 13.0 and Process Efficiency 61.8%.
Figure 7. A stockout just after noon: no parts, a full Repair Queue, and Check In stopped.

Two hours after the order, the box lands and the repairs move on. After noon it happens again; at the 30th job, Chapter 8’s message stops the run (click Continue); late in the day the shelf runs out once more, for less than an hour.

Step 6. Read the cards

Simulation Complete reads 60.00 entities processed. The cards read Throughput 60.0 per day, Avg Throughput Time 70 min, WIP 0.0 and Process Efficiency 23.7%.
Figure 8. A Monday with parts: 60 customers, 70 minutes in the shop, 23.7% efficiency.
  • 60 went through.
  • Avg Throughput Time, 70 minutes, up from 51 in Chapter 8.
  • WIP, 0: at midnight the shop is empty.
  • Process Efficiency, 23.7%, down from 28.1%: more of each customer’s time is spent waiting.

Nothing about the staff or the steps changed. Nineteen extra minutes per customer came from the parts alone: a supply problem showing up as a waiting-room problem. That is the kind of cause a model finds that a look at the shop floor would miss. One run, one possible Monday. Click No.

Step 7. Save it

  1. Click File, then Save. Chapter 10 starts from this shop.

Your practice model

  1. Start fromChapter 8. Tag Each Customer and Count the JobsThe shop as Chapter 8 left it. Use your own saved Phone Repair Shop instead if you built it.
  2. Compare withChapter 9. Make Each Repair Wait for Its PartThe shop as this chapter leaves it. Open it when you are done, and check your settings against it.

Both are in File ▸ Demo Models, in the Self Teach Guide group. A demo model opens as a new model, so the original never changes.

Check yourself

  1. Question 1Why does the REQUEST go in the Repair Queue's logic and not in Repair's?
  2. Question 2The shelf orders a box of 10 when 3 are left, and a box takes 2 hours. When does a stockout happen?
  3. Question 3During the stockout, the Technicians are free but Check In is stopped. Why?

Try it yourself

Fix the stockouts with a smarter reorder rule, not more Technicians.

  1. Click the Parts Shelf, open the Items tab, and raise Reorder Level from 3 to 6, so the next box is ordered sooner.
  2. Run the day and read Avg Throughput Time before you answer Simulation Complete.

Mark it done

When you can explain how a parts shortage stops Check In, turn on Done.

You watched this chapter's video.Not watched yet: the video is marked when it plays to the end.

Kept in this browser only, and shown on the course page.

All 15 chapters of the Self Teach Guide